Are you tired of your cat turning up its nose at most of the food served? Are there just too many leftovers? It is a problem many cat parents consult me on during their visit to my veterinary clinic! Sometimes your loving cats can make you desperate for them to eat ANYTHING!
Looking for a cat food option for your picky cat? A cat food that is loved by many cats and is sworn by cat owners might be your best bet.
Our top pick and my personal favorite is Purina, Fancy Feast, Gravy Lovers. Tried and tested by thousands of cat moms and dads, It is an instant delight.
- Value For Money Cat Food
- Flavorful Protein In a Yummy Sauce
- Least Leftovers
It is made in the form of chunks in yummy gravy that cats lick and chew with ease. With the power to satisfy your cat’s taste buds, it comes with balanced nutrition that will keep your cat healthy.
However, if your cat still does not like this one, there are many other options from which you can choose. These options provide different features and health benefits as well.
This Article Will Explain & Discuss:
- Detailed Reviews On 10 Best Wet Cat Foods For Pick Eaters
- Likebale Ingredients In Cat Food For Pick Eaters
- FAQs Regarding Cat Food For Picky Eaters
Our Quick Comparison On The Best Wet Cat Food For Picky Eaters
| Image | Product | Features | Shop On |
|---|---|---|---|
TOP PICK |
| AmazonChewy | |
BEST PREMIUM  |
| AmazonChewy | |
BEST BUDGET  |
| AmazonChewy | |
BEST VETERINARY RECOMMENDED  |
| AmazonChewy | |
BEST FOR KITTENS  |
| AmazonChewy | |
BEST GRAIN FREE  |
| AmazonChewy | |
BEST NATURAL  |
| AmazonChewy | |
BEST BUDGET (DRY)  |
| AmazonChewy | |
BEST SEAFOOD (DRY)  |
| AmazonChewy | |
BEST CHICKEN (DRY)  |
| AmazonChewy |
Our Detailed Reviews On The Best Wet Cat Food For Picky Eaters
1. Purina, Fancy Feast, Gravy Lovers
- First 5 Ingredients:
- Turkey Feast: Poultry Broth, Turkey, Liver, Wheat Gluten, Meat By Products
- Chicken Feast: Poultry Broth, Chicken, Liver, Wheat Gluten, Meat By Products
- Beef Feast: Meat Broth, Beef, Liver, Wheat Gluten, Meat By Products
- Protein Source & Quantity:
- Turkey Feast: Turkey, 9.0% min (Crude Protein)
- Chicken Feast: Chicken, 9.0% min (Crude Protein)
- Beef Feast: Beef, 9.0% min (Crude Protein)
- Food Texture: Wet Food in the form of Chunks in Gravy
- Lifestage: Adult
Why Is It The Best Cat Food For Picky Eaters?
Fancy Feast is an ever loved cat food choice for cats that tend to be finicky or picky as some of mine. It has tremendously great reviews and is an overall winner.
It comes in chicken, beef, and turkey flavors which are among the top cat food flavors preferred by cats. Apart from good flavors, it is complete, balanced vitamins and minerals for cats. Mixing up flavors can keep your cat entertained and looking toward mealtimes.
It has soft and tender bites which have been slow-cooked for an attractive texture of chunks in gravy.
Chunks are easy to chew and digest which is good for the stomach of your cat. The gravy used in the recipe is thick and mouthwatering.
- Good For Picky Cats
- Assorted Flavors
- High-Quality Protein
- Cats Might Not Be a Fan of One of The Flavors, Then It Is Best To Buy Single Cans Instead of Assorted Packs
2. Sheba, Perfect Portions
- First 5 Ingredients: Water, Chicken, Poultry By Products, Animal Plasma, Tapioca Starch
- Protein Source & Quantity: Chicken, 7.0% min (Crude Protein)
- Type of Product: Grain-Free, No Corn No Wheat No Soy, Pea-Free
- Food Texture: Wet Food in the form of Cuts in Gravy
- Lifestage: Adult
Why Is It Good For Picky Eaters?
Sheba brings us a mix of premium ingredients which are sure to keep your cat indulged in mealtimes. It is made up of chicken which is the best source of animal protein and is a flavor loved by most cats.
The sizing of the trays is also perfect for cats owners who do not like leftovers.
Real chicken, beef, and turkey are the source of its protein along with a good mix of minerals, vitamins, fish oils, taurine, and fatty acids. All these ingredients are good for the cat’s hair, skin, development, and immunity.
This cat food is in the form of morsels which are soft irregular pieces. They will be easy to chew for the cat and also light on the digestive system.
The further health benefits of this food include that it has no artificial preservatives or favors. It also comes without the use of fillers like corn, soy, or wheat.
- Approved For Finicky Cats
- Easy To Digest And Hydrating
- No Artificial Additives
- Kibble May Clump If Not Stored Correctly
- Not Many Bag Sizes To Choose From
3. Purina Friskies, Shreds
(Multiple Flavors)
- First 5 Ingredients: Water, Liver, Chicken, Beef, Wheat Gluten, Turkey
- Protein Source & Quantity: Beef, 9.0% min (Crude Protein),
- Food Texture: Wet Food in the form of Shreds in Gravy
- Lifestage: Adult
Why Is It Good For Picky Eaters?
For cat owners who want to keep costs down while still satisfying their furry felines , I always recommend Friskies.
It contains a delicious sauce and gravy which is sure to keep your cat hydrated and fulfilled. The hydration in cat food also keeps it safe from urinary problems.
The food texture is shredded which makes your cat chew before swallowing which also being easy on the digestive system.
Real meat is a source of very good quality animal protein. It is also available in assorted flavors which keep your cat curious and awaiting mealtimes every day.
It is enhanced with minerals and vitamins for a daily dose of nutrition along with taurine which provides a good heart and vision.
- Majority Cat Favorite
- Good Quality Protein
- Enhanced With Vitamins And Minerals
- May Contain More Gravy As Compared To Some Other Brands
4. Hill’s Science Diet, Healthy Cuisine
- First 5 Ingredients: Chicken Broth, Chicken, Pork Liver, Carrots, Wheat Gluten
- Protein Source & Quantity: Chicken, 6.5% min (Crude Protein)
- Type of Product: With Grain
- Food Texture: Wet Food in the form of Chunks in Gravy
- Lifestage: Kitten
Why Is It Good For Picky Eaters?
Hill’s Science Diet is a carefully created cat food, with the help of vets and experts, after intensive research. It is a fast favorite of many cats while also providing many health benefits.
This cat food has real meat which activates the carnivorous instinct of cats and attracts them towards finishing up meals. It is made up of chunks in yummy sauce or gravy and resembles the natural diet of cats. Chunks are soft and easy to chew and digest while the gravy keeps your cat hydrated inside and out.
The meat used in this kitten food mix is roasted chicken which gives a nice cooked flavor of chicken to cats. Chicken is the most popular flavor among cats while also being the most nutritious.
It is free of artificial additives and preservatives. It contains taurine for healthy vision and a good heart. It is especially good for kittens who have developing bodies and cats who are nursing or pregnant.
- Picky Cat Favorite
- Balanced Diet
- Hydrating Wet Food
- Cats Who Like Pate Or Smaller, Creamier Textures May Not Be a Fan of This Chunky Mix
5. Royal Canin, Kitten
- First 5 Ingredients: Water Sufficient For Processing, Chicken By Products, Chicken, Chicken Liver, Pork Liver, Wheat Gluten
- Protein Source & Quantity: Chicken, 11.0% min (Crude Protein)
- Type of Product: With Grain
- Food Texture: Wet Food in the form of Thin Slices in Sauce
- Lifestage: Kitten
Why Is It Good For Picky Eaters?
If you have a picky kitten that won’t have what all the others are having, Royal Canin kitten food can save the day for you. It is a wet cat food formula that is preferred by the majority of cats worldwide, has received the best reviews from cat owners, and is highly suggested by both myself and many other cat owners. It is optimum for cats who are 12 months or older.
The texture of this food is tender and is a good partner for kittens as they switch from milk to solid foods. It is easy on the tummy and can be chewed easily.
The gravy of this food is also delectable while supporting hydration and regular stools.
This food mix contains the perfect ratio of fiber, prebiotics, and digestible proteins to keep the gut healthy and prevent any digestive problems in your growing kitten.
- Picky Eater Favorite
- Good For Digestion
- Supports Growing Kitten Bodies
- Works Well For Picky Eaters But May Be a Little Chunky For Kittens Who Tend To Eat Too Fast
6. Merrick Backcountry, Grain-Free
- First 5 Ingredients: Deboned Rabbit, Lamb Broth, Beef Broth, Beef Liver, Deboned Lamb
- Protein Source & Quantity: Rabbit, 9.0% min (Crude Protein)
- Type of Product: No Corn No Wheat No Soy, Gluten Free, Grain-Free, High-Protein, Pea-Free, Natural, Premium
- Food Texture: Wet Food in the form of Morsels in Gravy
- Lifestage: Adult
Why Is It Good For Picky Eaters?
Merrick Backcountry is a unique but loved recipe for cat food. It is a good grain-free recipe enjoyed by a lot of cats. If your cat loves rabbit meat, this is the best option for you.
It is packed full of animal protein along with a blast of flavor in thick gravy that your furry pal will finish in no time. Wet cat foods include gravy and good hydration content which keeps your cat hydrated in the tummy.
Some cat owners swear that it is hard for them to switch their cats to dry food after giving them a taste of this gravy-filled goodness.
Taking about the benefits on your cat’s current health condition, it is grain-free so expect only real rabbit wholesomeness. Apart from that, it contains proteins, and is antioxidant-rich to keep your cat energetic and preserve immunity.
- Agrees With Picky Cats
- Grain-Free Wholesome Goodness
- Immunity Boosting
- Not An Immediate Favorite For Cats Who Prefer Smaller Bits Or Creamier Textures of Food
7. Fussie Cat, Premium
- First 5 Ingredients: Tuna, Water Sufficient For Processing, Chicken Meat, Sunflower Seed Oil, Calcium Carbonate
- Protein Source & Quantity: Tuna, 12.0% min (Crude Protein)
- Type of Product: Grain-Free, Pea-Free, Natural
- Food Texture: Wet Food in the form of Aspic or Gelee
- Lifestage: Adult
Why Is It Good For Picky Eaters?
Fussy brings us an all-natural cat food made with tuna and served in the form of jelly. It may be a new kind of texture for your cat to try or an oft-loved one as sworn by many users of this mix. Unlike other cat foods in gravies, this is made up of gelatinous sauce which encases the other ingredients.
This cat food is especially good for cats going through teeth or gum-related problems. It is really easy to chew and even easier to digest. Moreover, your cats will love it! Let’s face it, which cat doesn’t like tuna?
It does not contain ingredients that bring the animal protein quantity down such as grains or potatoes. These are also not good for cats with allergies.
Full of omegas, it keeps the fur coat nice and healthy. Low in saturated fats, it contains animal fat which is easier for cats to absorb. It has good quality vitamins to keep your cat nutritiously balanced.
- All Natural Ingredients.
- Good For Picky Cats
- Jelly Texture Good For Cats With Teeth Issues
- Food Includes Carrageenan
Some Options of Best Dry Foods For Picky Eaters
8. Meow Mix, Original Choice
- First 5 Ingredients: Ground Yellow Corn, Corn Gluten Meal, Chicken By Product Meal, Soybean Meal, Beef Tallow
- Protein Source & Quantity: Chicken, turkey, salmon and ocean fish, 31.0% min (Crude Protein)
- Type of Product: With Grain
- Food Texture: Dry Food
- Lifestage: Adult
Why Is It Good For Picky Eaters?
Meow Mix is a good option for pet owners who would like something that fits their budget in dry cat foods, for picky cats.
It combines all the tastes cats adore, including chicken, turkey, salmon, and fish from the sea. Many cats all over the world enjoy this food, and it has helped many of my fellow cat-moms feel less stressed.
It has a nice aromatic kibble which is medium-sized and is enjoyed by cats who like a crunch. It contains coloring and flavoring to attract really finicky cats.
Apart from being loved, it has high quality protein which is good to keep your cat strong and energetic. Energy adds many health benefits and makes the cat playful and healthy for long.
It also contains all the minerals and vitamins required for balanced nutrition. The fatty acids support the fur coat of the cat keeping it strong and shiny.
- Winner Among Picky Cats
- Seafood Flavors
- Balanced Nutrition
- It Has Limited Options For Size
9. Friskies, Seafood Sensations
- First 5 Ingredients: Ground Yellow Corn, Corn Gluten Meal, Poultry ByProduct Meal,
- Soybean Meal, Animal Fat Preserved With Mixed-Tocopherols
- Protein Source & Quantity: Tuna, shrimp, salmon, 30.0% min (Crude Protein)
- Food Texture: Dry Food
- Lifestage: For all life stages
Why Is It Good For Picky Eaters?
Friskies cat food has a good seafood option with premium ingredients which many picky eaters have approved.
If your cat is a picky eater but more inclined towards seafood then this food is a must-buy. The kibble is enjoyed by cats who crave crunch and prefer crunchier meals to softer ones.
Crunchy dry foods keep the cat’s teeth free from plaque and makes them healthy and strong.
It contains real seafood to attract cats to their natural prey. It also contains antioxidants that keep the cat’s coat healthy and strong.
The added minerals and vitamins will keep your cat overall satisfied and nutritious.
- Real Ingredients
- Favorite Of Many Cats
- Balanced Nutrition
- Not Ideal For Cats With Teeth Problems
10. Blue Buffalo, Wilderness
- First 5 Ingredients: Deboned Chicken, Chicken Meal, Pea Protein, Tapioca Starch, Peas
- Protein Source & Quantity: Chicken, 40.0% min (Crude Protein)
- Type of Product: Grain-Free, High-Protein, No Corn No Wheat No Soy, Natural
- Food Texture: Dry Food
- Lifestage: Adult
Why Is It Good For Picky Eaters?
Blue Buffaloes brings its appealing chicken recipe into the playing field for picky eaters. This cat food is enjoyed by cats who prefer chicken to seafood, and dry food to wet ones. While wet food comes with its own appeal and advantages, dry food has its own attraction for cats and benefits as well.
One of the benefits includes gum and teeth health for cats who chew the crunchy kibble. This removes the plaque from their teeth and makes the gums and jaw stronger. It also prevents cats from swallowing food whole without chewing.
This food enjoys its attraction and popularity among cats along with many other health benefits. These include the use of chicken as its main source of protein. This animal protein is high quality which gives cats the essential strength and energy that they need.
Omega fatty acids come into play to strengthen and smooth the cat’s fur. The grain-free formula is good for cats with allergies and intolerances. It also contains healthy carbs which fuel your cat with energy.
- Good For Finicky Cats
- Chicken Recipe
- High Protein Diet
- Bigger Kibbles Can Be Harder To Chew For Cats With Tooth Sensitivities
Guide To Buying The Best Wet Cat Food for Picky Eaters
Have a picky one and nothing seems to satisfy their taste buds? Here are some tips and tricks to choose the best tasting cat foods for picky eaters:
1. Appealing Aroma
Since cats have a very heightened sense of smell (ever notice your cat sniffing each and every corner around a new room? Yes, that’s what I’m talking about), foods that have strong smells will have a way with them. They will either like it or reject it. Foods that have vague smells will not do the job.
You should choose a cat food that has a strong smell like cooked poultry and oily fish. One tip to make food give off more smell is to heat it up.
Foods rich in protein and fat tend to attract most cats. The more the ‘stink’, the more it is likely to appeal to your cat.
2. Texture & Shape
The second thing that a cat depends upon while choosing what to eat is is the way the cat food feels in its mouth. Wet cat foods come in different textures like pate, minced, gravies, morsels, flaked, chunky, shredded, sliced, etc.
You can read the specifications of each texture and shape here.
You, as the pet owner, will need to figure out what kind of texture and shape your cats likes best. This can be done through food trials. In this method, you will be putting out small amounts of cat food of different textures and shapes to see what your cat likes best.
To help with these trials, some cat food brands offer a refund on cat food that your cat rejects.
3. Animal Protein Source
The third most important thing is the source of protein that you are offering. Consider that the food has a strong smell that reaches your cat, but does your cat ‘like’ the smell?
Different cats have different food preferences, just like humans. Some cats might like chicken while some may have fish as their favorite. So it is important to know what ingredient your cat likes best.
This can also be achieved through food trails with different sources of protein laid out for your cat to choose from.
4. Temperature
Cats are carnivorous hunters by nature. Keeping this in mind, it is conclusive that they prefer cat foods that are close to their own body temperatures, which is about 101 Fahrenheit.
Food kept in the refrigerator will need to be warmed up a little.
5. Wet Food or Mix Diet
Giving your cat wet food, dry food, or a mixed diet is really just a matter of hydration. If your cat is going through hydration problems, then it may be a good idea to give them wet cat food. You can also give them a mixed diet on and off.
If your cat likes a crunchy bite every now and then, then a mixed diet would be nice.
6. Variety
Sometimes cats can get bored of the same kind of food. It has been reported by several cat owners for food products that their cats loved the food when served for the first time and grew bored of it with time. So it is normal for you to try new cat food flavors, and textures to keep things mixed up.
Variety also keeps cats fulfilled as there are many different sources of animal protein available which offer different benefits and nutrients. Whereas some textures are good for the teeth and gums. So it is good to use a variety of foods and not just stick to one.
7. Strict Feeding Times
Having strict feeding times can reduce pickiness in cats. This way, the cat waits for its food and is more likely to finish up what is offered.
If the food is available at all times, then your cat may get bored with it faster or this will just reduce the general attraction.
Strict feeding times are also a healthier option as it decreases chances of overeating. Finally, You are also able to monitor your cat meals better.
8. Establish Food Preference As Kittens
Just like humans, cats should be subjected to different variations in food ever since they are kittens. There is a chance that cats will develop pickiness towards cat foods that they were not served as kittens.
So offering varied kitten food if a good option i.e. different kinds of proteins along with different textures and shapes to make them familiar and comfortable with all food types.
FAQs: Best Wet Cat Food For Picky Eaters
Why Are Cats Picky Eaters?
Food preferences for cats are developed when they are kittens so it is important to introduce a variety of diets to them otherwise they can be picky. However, some cats may just have different preferences for flavors and textures, just like humans.
Cats also have carnivorous instincts so they will like high protein, and fewer carbs diets more than others.
What Will A Picky Cat Eat?
Choice of cat food for picky eaters depends upon their protein choices and preference for texture and shape. For picky cats it is good to introduce food trails and observe the flavors and textures that they like to eat. You would also benefit from giving a small amount of new food before getting bigger packs to test it out first.
Factors including cat food preferences include stress and environment. Cats eat better when they are relaxed. Aroma and smells are also a big factor in the attraction towards meals.
When Should You Worry About Picky Eaters?
You should worry that your cat is being finicky when you observe that it is starting to lose weight when there is leftover food in the container or changed behavior in the cat such as overly aggressive or lazy.
It is very important to observe your cat every day. The way that your cat acts can tell a lot. Additionally, you should also look out for physical health condition.
How Do I Introduce A New Food To My Cat?
The way to introduce new food to cats is to let them go through a transition period. You can mix the food with the old one and gradually increase the quantity before switching it out completely.
A good tip is to check your cat’s reaction with a small pack or tester of the new food first before getting a big bag.
Is Wet Food Better For Picky Cats?
Wet food is better for cats in the sense that it has good water content. Since cats do not derive much of their hydration from drinking water, then this is a good thing for them.
So, if your cat is going through dehydration, then it is a good idea to switch them to a wet food diet.
Wet cat food for is also better as it is closer to the natural feed for cats in the wild. Dry cat food can also have more carbs, but there are fewer carb options available as well, so wet food does not necessarily take the win against dry. It is more of a matter of what your cat requires or prefers.
How Do I Make Food More Appealing And Tasty For My Cat?
You can make food more appealing to your cat by serving it at a good temperature. The temperature that a cat likes its food to be in, is usually nearer to its own body temperature which is 101 Fahrenheit.
Other than that, you can set mealtimes so that your cat will be looking forward to the food at that specific time. You should also go for food options with flavors and textures that your cat prefers.
What If My Cat Refuses To Eat?
If your cat refuses to eat then there may be a chance that the food served is not according to its liking. It may be due to a new cat food product.
However, if there is no change and the cat abruptly stops eating and starts to lose weight then you may want to visit the vet.
How Can I Add Moisture Content To My Cat’s Dry Food?
This usually concerns cat parents with cats that love dry food. Adding wet cat food as a topper will add the required moisture content in your cat’s meal.
What Ingredients & Human Foods Are Unhealthy or Toxic For Cats?
Human food is not for cats and it should not be given to them on a regular basis. Table scraps can also be the cause of intolerances among cats.
Here are all the foods that are toxic for your cat.
Our Verdict
Some of the best tasting cat foods for picky eaters have been listed, from my personal experience, and that are tried and tested by many picky cat parents.
While one cat may love one kind of flavor, another may like something else, and that is why we have so many options. I find the elimination diet to be the best way of figuring cats out.
However, an overall good cat food option for picky cats is Purina, Fancy Feast, Gravy Lovers which is loved by a vast majority of kitties.
- Value For Money Cat Food
- Flavorful Protein In a Yummy Sauce
- Least Leftovers
